Duuuuh, duh, duh, duh, duh, duuuuh, da, da, da da, duh, da, duh, duh, da, duh, daaa, duh, da, da, duh, crash.........Two Worlds Collide
Today is the Harvard University Commencement, and according the Boston Globe article from June 2, 2009, Chanequa Campbell will not be participating in the ceremonies. Chanequa is one of the young women connected to the May 19th murder of a drug dealer inside her dorm doorway. She is also a native of Bedford-Stuyvesant and alumnus of The Packer Collegiate Institute. But the Globe today is implying that her old world has invaded her new world of Harvard.
Chanequa came from a single parent home, got recruited into Prep for Prep, played sports, got diagnosed with lupus, and successfully completed Packer Collegiate to then major in sociology at Harvard, study abroad in London one year and work at Goldman Sachs one summer. So where is her world?
Writers are trying to make a point here, but they say that guns, drugs, and murder are straight out of Bed-Stuy (as if those things do not exist in Boston and Cambridge, Northeastern or Harvard). There seems to be a “hood culture” and an “Ivy League” culture, and this is making people wonder how and when the two shall meet. Some black leaders want to hold the Ivies responsible for transitioning students to fit into its world. Yes, they should or society should work so that they are not such disparities between the worlds. Other people want to talk about drug use on campus. Other people want to know why she is barred from graduating. I am wondering if she still gets the degree if she completes coursework.
I’m putting on a conspiratorial hat right now. Is Harvard being protected at the expense of Chanequa? What other students have been charged with crimes or misconduct at the university and how were their consequences handled? I am certain that Chanequa did something wrong, at the least a few bad decisions, but I hesitate to think that it is all because of Bed-Stuy. I happened to have hobnobbed with the Ivy League students and can speak from experience about how much drugs and alcohol live on campuses. Some dormmates of (a friend of) mine (wink) had rituals for test-taking that included bongs and beer (which often led to destruction of property) and now these young people are doctors, lawyers, and investment bankers. They were not from Bed-Stuy but Greenwich, CT, Princeton, NJ, and Brentwood, CA. When they participated in misconduct, their social capital played in their favor. Most universities have excellent PR offices and keep many things on campus, unless it is large enough to make the news. Where is Chanequa’s social capital and her network? I hate to think that the programs and people who believe that our beginnings do not define what we become abandon those they take on as projects. Some of these people are already speaking about her in past tense, as if her future is dead. Let us not ever do that.
I will hypothesize this… A ‘dime bag’ is $10, so $1,000 is probably the sum total of hallways and dormitories full of students. Since most students do not have money to buy all of the bags, there should be a list of students connected to this particular supplier. Chanequa probably still has family in Bed-Stuy. She might not have the luxury to walk away from Bed-Stuy as if it is a suitcase you can put in a closet. She might not have been fully embraced in the world of Harvard, especially if everybody knows where she’s from and what tuition she’s not paying. For urban kids, going to the Ivy League does not always come with liberation from everything that might have oppressed them and freedom to soar without restraint. I wonder what kind of lawyer she has…
I do not have all the facts. I do not believe that she should have connected herself to deleterious activities nor do I believe that she should not face consequences. I do not know what the policy is for commencement participation, but I know what commencement means. I challenge the imbalanced view presented about her negotiation between worlds and the fact that there is acceptance of so many worlds inside this country. She has contacts in Manhattan, London, Milan, and Cambridge. So she doesn’t have an old world and a new world. She actually has the whole world...if we don’t take it all away from her.
Check out the
article@http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2009/06/02/as_graduation_nears_a_harvard_senior_finds_herself_in_trouble?mode=PF….tell us what you think.